Table 1: In vitro/animal Synergy Studies for Staphylococcus aureus
Highlighted: synergistic interaction
Reference Number |
Combinations |
Pathogen |
Test Method |
Interaction |
Definition |
Tsuji, 2006 |
Dapto+Vanco |
hGISA |
E-test |
Additive |
FIC index > 0.5 < |
Credito, 2007 |
Dapto + Gent |
MSSA MRSA(CA, HA, PVL+/-) VISA VRSA |
Time kill |
Synergistic |
>2 log10 decrease in CFU/ml |
Tsuji, 2006 |
|
hGISA |
E-test Time kill |
Additive Additive |
FIC index >0.5 to ≤1 1to 2-log10 CFU/ml at 24h
|
Snydman, 2005 |
|
MRSA |
Checkerboard Time-kill |
Synergistic |
FIC index ≤ 0.5 Reduction >2 log10 CFU/ml |
Tsuji, 2005
|
|
GISA MSSA MRSA |
E-test Time-kill Time-kill |
Additive Enhance 24h Enhance 4-24h |
FIC index >0.5 to
≤1 > 20-log2- log10 CFU/ml
|
LaPlante, 2004 |
|
MSSA/MRSA |
Time-kill |
Increased bacteriocidal activity |
The time to 99% bacteriocidal kill by 3.8h to 5.2h (statistically not significant) |
Sakoulas, 2003 |
Dapto+Rif |
MRSA |
Animal study (vegetation bacterial density) |
Superior to monotherapy |
The difference of mean bacterial densities between dapto + rif and dapto monotherapy was statistically significant (p=0.006) |
Baltch, 2007 |
Dapto+Gent+Rif |
MRSA |
Time-kill using Monocyte-derived Macrophages (MDM), |
Superior to monotherapy |
Greater activitiy than double or single (p<0.01) |
Tsuji, 2006
|
Linez + Vanco |
hGISA |
E-test |
Additive |
FIC index > 0.5 to < 1 |
Grohs, 2003
|
|
MSSA/MRSA |
Time-kill |
Antagonistic |
Decrease 100-hold at 24/48h |
Chiang, 2003
|
|
MRSA |
Checkerboard |
Indifferent |
|
Jacqueline, 2003
|
|
MRSA |
Time-kill |
Indifferent |
|
Allen, 2002 |
|
MSSA/MRSA/MRSE |
In vitro pharmaco-dynamic model |
Improvement |
Increase in kill <2- log10 CFU/ml |
Grohs, 2003
|
Linez+Gent |
MSSA/MRSA |
Time-kill |
Indifferent |
|
Jacqueline, 2003 |
|
MRSA |
Time-kill |
Antagonistic |
Increase C.C >2- log10 CFU/ml |
LaPlante, 2004 |
|
MSSA/MRSA |
Time-kill |
Indifferent |
|
Grohs, 2003
|
Linez + Rif |
MSSA/MRSA |
Time-kill |
Indifferent |
|
Jacqueline, 2003 |
|
MRSA |
Time-kill |
Synergistic |
Decrease C.C >2- log10 CFU/ml |
Dailey, 2003 |
|
MSSA |
Experimental endocarditis model |
Indifferent |
|
Allen, 2002 |
Linez + QD |
MRSA |
In vitro pharmacodynamic model |
Enhance |
Increase in kill >2- log10 CFU/ml |
Sahuquillo Arce, 2006 |
Linez + fosfomycin |
MSSA |
Time-kill Checkerboard |
Synergistic |
Decrease >2- log10 CFU/ml FIC index < 0.5 |
Jacqueline, 2006 |
Linez + Ertapenem |
MRSA |
Time-kill, Dynamic checkerboard (in vivo IE model) |
Synergistic |
Decrease >2- log10 CFU/ml
|
Jacqueline, 2005 |
Linez + Imipenem |
hGISA |
Time-kill, Dynamic checkerboard |
Synergistic |
Decrease C.C. >2- log10 CFU/ml
|
Tsuji, 2006
|
Q/D+Vanco |
hGISA GISA |
Time-kill E-test |
Synergistic Additive |
>2- log10 CFU/ml at 24h FIC index > 0.5 to < 1 |
Kang, 1995
|
|
MRSA/MSSA |
Time-kill |
Additive |
TR:>5-log10 CFU/ml |
Allen, 2002
|
|
MRSA |
In vitro pharmacodynamic model |
Enhance |
Increase in kill >2- log10 CFU/ml |
Kang , 1997 |
|
MSSA/MRSA |
Time-kill |
Synergistic |
Reduction >2- log10 CFU/ml at 24 h |
Tsuji, 2006 |
Q/D + Gent |
hGISA
GISA |
E-test Time-kill E-test Time-kill |
Indifferent Indifferent Indifferent Indifferent |
FIC index >0.5 to < 1 1 to 2- log10 CFU/ml at 24h |
Zarrouk, 2001
|
Q/D+Rif |
S. aureus (HM1054, RP13, HM1054R) |
Time kill Animal study (IE model) |
Bactericidal Bactericidal |
Decrease 3-log10 CFU/ml Decrease 3-log10 CFU/ml |
Hamel, 2008 |
Q/D+Rif |
MRSA |
In vivo, rabbit arthritis model |
Synergistic |
No definition log10 CFU/ml reduction: -3.4 ±0.5 (p=0.0005 vs control) |
Sambatakou, 1998 |
|
MRSA |
Time-kill |
Synergistic |
Decrease >2- log10 CFU/ml |
Petersen, 2006 |
Tige+Vanco |
MRSA |
Checkerboard Time-kill |
Indifferent Indifferent |
|
Mercier, 2002 |
Tige+Gent |
MRSA GISA |
Time-kill Time-kill |
Enhance Improve |
> 100-hold or > in kill at 24h < 100-hold |
Petersen, 2006 |
Tige+Rif |
MRSA |
Checkerboard Time-kill |
Indifferent Indifferent |
|
Palmer, 1996
|
Levo+Rif |
MSSA MRRA |
Time-kill Time-kill |
Indifferent Indifferent |
Mean CFU at 72h was ind. Mean CFU at 72h was ind. |
Kang, 1994 |
|
MSSA MRSA |
Checkerboard Checkerboard |
Synergistic Synergistic |
FIC index < 0.5 FIX index < 0.5 |
Dapto: Daptomycin Linez: Linezolid Q/D: Quinupristin/dalfopristin Tige:Tigecycline IE: Infectious endocarditis
Levo: Levofloxacin Vanco: Vancomycin Gent: Gentamicin Rif: rifampin
hGISA: heterogeneous glycopeptide-intermediate Staphylococcus aureus HA: Hospital acquired CA: Community acquired PVL: Panton-Valentine leukocidin
TR: Total reduction C.C: Colony count
FIC: Fractional inhibitory concentration
Enhance: Enhancement Improve: Improvement